Negotiate Property Insurance

As a seasoned professional in the commercial real estate industry, I’ve seen firsthand the importance of having a solid property insurance policy. However, simply having insurance isn’t enough; you must also be prepared to negotiate effectively with your insurance company when the need arises.

In my 18 years of experience representing business owners and landlords, I’ve learned that the key to successful negotiations is a combination of knowledge, preparation, and strategic communication. Whether you’re dealing with a minor claim or a major loss, the ability to negotiate can make a significant difference in the outcome.

In this comprehensive guide, I’ll share my insights and strategies for mastering the art of property insurance negotiation. We’ll cover everything from understanding your policy to maximizing your discounts and navigating the claims process. By the end of this article, you’ll have the tools and confidence you need to advocate for yourself and your property effectively.

Key Takeaways

  • Understanding your property insurance policy is crucial for effective negotiations
  • Preparing a detailed inventory and gathering evidence can strengthen your claim
  • Hiring a public adjuster or attorney may be beneficial in complex cases

Understanding Your Property Insurance Policy 

Before you can effectively negotiate with your insurance company, you must have a clear understanding of your property insurance policy. Here are the key components to focus on:

A. Types of coverage

  1. Dwelling coverage: This covers the structure of your property, including walls, roof, and foundation.
  2. Personal property coverage: This covers your belongings inside the property, such as furniture and equipment.
  3. Liability coverage: This protects you if someone is injured on your property and sues you.
  4. Additional living expenses: If your property becomes uninhabitable, this coverage helps pay for temporary housing and related expenses.

B. Deductibles and premiums

Your deductible is the amount you agree to pay out of pocket before your insurance coverage kicks in. Generally, a higher deductible means a lower premium, and vice versa. It’s essential to find a balance that works for your budget and risk tolerance.

C. Exclusions and limitations

Every policy has exclusions and limitations, which outline what is not covered. Common exclusions include flood and earthquake damage, which often require separate policies. Be sure to review your policy carefully and ask your agent about any unclear terms.

D. Flood and earthquake insurance considerations

If your property is in an area prone to floods or earthquakes, you may need to purchase additional coverage. These policies have their own deductibles and premiums, so factor them into your overall insurance budget.

It’s important to note that many reinsurance companies are abandoning high-risk states altogether, and those that stay are raising rates by 45-100%, according to Danielle Lombardo, chair of Lockton Global Real Estate, a New York-based advisory firm. This trend can make it more challenging and expensive to obtain adequate coverage in these areas.

“The devil is in the details when it comes to property insurance. Take the time to read and understand your policy before you need to use it.” – Mike Tolj

Preparing for Insurance Negotiations 

Preparation is key to successful insurance negotiations. Here’s what you should do before filing a claim:

A. Assessing your property’s value

  1. Home appraisal: Hire a professional appraiser to determine your property’s current market value.
  2. Replacement cost vs. actual cash value: Understand the difference between these two valuation methods and which one your policy uses.

B. Documenting your belongings

  1. Home inventory: Create a detailed list of all your belongings, including purchase dates, prices, and receipts when possible.
  2. Receipts and photographs: Keep receipts for major purchases and take photographs or videos of your property and belongings regularly.

C. Identifying potential risks and vulnerabilities

  1. Natural disasters: Know what natural disasters are common in your area and how they could affect your property.
  2. Home security measures: Implement security measures such as alarms, cameras, and locks to deter theft and vandalism.

D. Gathering evidence to support your claim

If you experience a loss, gather as much evidence as possible to support your claim. This may include:

  • Police reports
  • Witness statements
  • Contractor estimates
  • Photographs or videos of the damage

E. Understanding your rights as a policyholder

Familiarize yourself with your state’s insurance laws and your rights as a policyholder. For example, most states require insurance companies to respond to claims within a certain timeframe and provide a reason for any denials.

Keep recordsMaintain a file with your policy documents, inventory, and any correspondence with your insurance company.
Stay organizedCreate a timeline of events and keep track of deadlines and important dates related to your claim.
Communicate in writingWhenever possible, communicate with your insurance company in writing to create a paper trail.

Negotiating with Your Insurance Company 

Now that you’re prepared, it’s time to start the negotiation process. Here’s what you need to know:

A. Filing a claim

  1. Contacting your insurance agent: Notify your agent as soon as possible after a loss occurs.
  2. Providing necessary documentation: Submit your home inventory, receipts, and any other evidence to support your claim.

B. Communicating with insurance adjusters

  1. Being prompt and responsive: Return calls and emails from your adjuster in a timely manner.
  2. Presenting your case effectively: Clearly explain the extent of your loss and why you believe it should be covered under your policy.

C. Countering low settlement offers

  1. Knowing your policy’s limits: Be aware of your policy’s coverage limits and how they apply to your claim.
  2. Using evidence to justify your claim: Use your home inventory, receipts, and other evidence to demonstrate the value of your loss.

“Remember, the insurance adjuster’s job is to minimize the company’s payout. Your job is to ensure you receive a fair settlement. Don’t be afraid to negotiate.” – Mike Tolj

D. Hiring a public adjuster or attorney

  1. When to consider professional help: If you have a large or complex claim, or if you feel the insurance company is not treating you fairly, consider hiring a public adjuster or attorney.
  2. Benefits and drawbacks: Public adjusters and attorneys can provide expertise and advocacy, but they also charge fees. Weigh the potential benefits against the costs.

E. Dealing with claim denials and disputes

If your claim is denied or you disagree with the settlement offer, you have options:

  • Request a review by a supervisor or manager
  • File a formal appeal with the insurance company
  • File a complaint with your state’s insurance department
  • Consider mediation or arbitration
  • Consult with an attorney

Maximizing Your Insurance Discounts 

While negotiating a claim is important, it’s also crucial to ensure you’re getting the best possible rate on your property insurance. Here are some ways to maximize your discounts:

A. Home improvements and upgrades

  1. Storm shutters and roof reinforcement: Installing storm shutters and reinforcing your roof can help protect your property from wind and hail damage.
  2. Smoke detectors and security systems: Adding smoke detectors and a security system can qualify you for discounts and help prevent losses.

B. Bundling policies

If you have multiple insurance policies, such as auto and property, consider bundling them with the same company for a discount.

C. Loyalty and long-term policyholder discounts

Some insurance companies offer discounts for long-term policyholders or those who renew their policies consistently.

D. Maintaining a good credit score

Many insurance companies use credit scores as a factor in determining premiums. Maintaining a good credit score can help you qualify for lower rates.

E. Regularly reviewing and updating your coverage

Review your policy annually and update it as needed to ensure you have the right coverage and are taking advantage of any available discounts.

DiscountPotential Savings
Multi-policy bundling10-20%
Home safety features5-15%
Good credit10-30%
Negotiate Property Insurance

Common Pitfalls to Avoid in Insurance Negotiations 

While negotiating with your insurance company, be sure to avoid these common pitfalls:

A. Accepting the first settlement offer

The first offer from your insurance company is often lower than what you’re entitled to. Don’t be afraid to negotiate for a higher settlement.

B. Failing to document damages and expenses

Keep detailed records of all damages and expenses related to your claim. Without proper documentation, it can be difficult to prove the extent of your loss.

C. Neglecting to read and understand your policy

Make sure you thoroughly read and understand your insurance policy before a loss occurs. Ignorance of your policy’s terms and conditions can lead to surprises and disputes later on.

D. Engaging in insurance fraud

Never exaggerate or falsify information on your claim. Insurance fraud is a serious crime and can result in denied claims, cancelled policies, and legal consequences.

E. Delaying the claims process

Report losses promptly and respond to your insurance company’s requests for information in a timely manner. Delaying the process can hinder your ability to negotiate effectively.

Alternative Dispute Resolution 

If you reach an impasse with your insurance company, alternative dispute resolution methods can help you resolve the issue without going to court. Here are a few options:

A. Mediation

In mediation, a neutral third party helps you and the insurance company reach a mutually acceptable agreement. The mediator does not make a decision but rather facilitates communication and negotiation.

B. Arbitration

Arbitration is similar to mediation but more formal. An arbitrator, who is often an attorney or retired judge, hears evidence from both sides and makes a binding decision.

C. Appraisal

If you disagree with the insurance company’s valuation of your loss, you can invoke the appraisal clause in your policy. Each party hires an appraiser, and the two appraisers select a third appraiser to act as an umpire. The appraisers and umpire then determine the value of the loss.

Navigating the Claims Process for Specific Scenarios 

Different types of losses require different approaches to the claims process. Here are a few common scenarios:

A. Theft and burglary claims

  • File a police report immediately
  • Provide your insurance company with a copy of the report and a list of stolen items
  • If you have receipts or photographs of the stolen items, submit them with your claim

B. Fire and smoke damage claims

  • Contact your insurance company and the fire department as soon as possible
  • Document the damage with photographs and videos
  • Keep receipts for any temporary repairs or living expenses

C. Wind and hail damage claims

  • Document the damage with photographs and videos
  • Obtain estimates from licensed contractors for repairs
  • Be prepared for the insurance company to send an engineer or inspector to assess the damage

D. Water damage and flood claims

  • Document the source and extent of the damage
  • If the damage is from a flood, file a claim with your flood insurance provider
  • Keep receipts for any temporary repairs or water extraction services

E. Liability claims

  • If someone is injured on your property, attend to their immediate medical needs
  • Contact your insurance company and provide them with details of the incident
  • Avoid admitting fault or liability without consulting your insurance company or attorney
Negotiate Property Insurance


What should I do if my insurance company denies my claim? 

If your claim is denied, request a written explanation of the denial and review your policy to ensure the reason for denial is valid. If you disagree with the decision, file an appeal with the insurance company and consider hiring a public adjuster or attorney.

How long does the insurance claim process typically take? 

The length of the claim process varies depending on the complexity of the claim and the responsiveness of both parties. Simple claims may be resolved in a few weeks, while more complex claims could take several months.

What is the difference between replacement cost and actual cash value coverage? 

Replacement cost coverage pays to repair or replace your property with materials of similar kind and quality, without deducting for depreciation. Actual cash value coverage pays the depreciated value of your property, which may not be enough to fully replace it.

How can I negotiate a better settlement offer from my insurance company? 

To negotiate a better settlement offer, provide evidence to support the value of your claim, such as contractor estimates, receipts, and photographs. Be persistent and don’t be afraid to ask for a higher amount if you believe it’s justified.

What should I do if I suspect my insurance company is acting in bad faith? 

If you believe your insurance company is acting in bad faith, such as by unreasonably denying or delaying your claim, file a complaint with your state’s insurance department. You may also want to consult with an attorney specializing in insurance law.

What steps should I take when filing a property damage insurance claim?

When filing a property damage insurance claim, document the damage with photographs, contact your insurance provider immediately, and follow their instructions for submitting a claim accurately and efficiently.

How can I negotiate with an insurance company for a fair claim payout?

You can negotiate with an insurance company for a fair claim payout by presenting evidence of the damage, researching the value of the loss, seeking multiple estimates for repairs, and being persistent in your communication with the insurer.


Negotiating with your property insurance company can be a daunting task, but with the right knowledge and preparation, you can advocate for yourself effectively. Remember to understand your policy, document your losses, and be persistent in your negotiations.

If you need assistance navigating the complex world of property insurance, don’t hesitate to reach out to a professional. As a seasoned commercial real estate expert, I’m here to help you protect your investments and achieve your goals.

Are you ready to take control of your property insurance? Schedule a consultation with me today and let’s discuss how I can help you master the art of negotiation.

Blog Articles Disclaimer

The information presented in articles on our website or affiliated platforms is exclusively intended for informational purposes. It’s crucial to grasp that this content does not constitute professional advice or services. We strongly recommend our readers to seek guidance from appropriately qualified experts, including, but not limited to, real estate and other attorneys, accountants, financial planners, bankers, mortgage professionals, architects, government officials, engineers, and related professionals. These experts can offer personalized counsel tailored to the specific nuances of your individual circumstances. Relying on the content without consulting the relevant experts may hinder informed decision-making. Consequently, neither Tolj Commercial Real Estate nor its agents assume any responsibility for potential consequences that may arise from such action.

Similar Posts