tenant screening for commercial properties

Are you interested in leasing out a commercial property but unsure of the best rental screening process? It can be challenging to vet potential tenants for any type of rental: from single-family homes to multifamily dwellings. However, when it comes to large commercial holdings, conducting thorough tenant screenings is even more important as the stakes are higher—both financially and legally. Luckily, there are several strategies available that commercial landlords can use to effectively evaluate candidates and ensure they have chosen a reliable option. In this post, we’ll discuss ten tips on how you can screen your tenants properly so you can rest assured that the people living in or using your commercial spaces uphold their end of the agreement.

Effective commercial tenant screening is crucial in attracting well-deserving tenants. By carefully examining potential renters’ business credit scores, personal credit ratings, background checks, references, and more, you can make informed decisions about their suitability as tenants for your commercial space. This comprehensive evaluation process ensures that you choose tenants who will be a valuable asset to your property.

Key Takeaways

  • Effective tenant screening for commercial real estate is essential to safeguarding your investment and ensuring long-term business success.
  • Understanding and adhering to legal requirements, thoroughly gathering and verifying potential tenant information, and interpreting business credit reports are crucial steps in the screening process.
  • Proper screening not only helps in finding financially stable tenants but also builds a strong foundation for a successful and profitable leasing relationship.
tenant screening for commercial properties

The Basics of Commercial Tenant Screening

Commercial tenant screening is an essential part of the process of leasing commercial property, like offices, shops, or industrial spaces. It’s a process that helps property owners to assess potential tenants based on a variety of factors that can help predict the tenant’s business performance and reliability in fulfilling lease obligations. The process differs from residential tenant screening in several significant ways.

Firstly, residential tenant screening primarily focuses on the personal aspects of potential tenants, such as their income, employment stability, credit history, and references. The goal is to ensure that the potential tenant can afford to pay rent regularly and will respect the property and community rules.

For example, when someone seeks to rent a two-bedroom apartment in downtown New York, the landlord may evaluate their credit score, and employment verification, and speak with former landlords to assess their rental payment capability and responsibility as a tenant.

In contrast, commercial tenant screening takes into consideration the financial health and reputation of a business, as well as the business owner’s credibility. It’s about assessing whether the business can sustain the lease obligations over the long term and whether it is a suitable tenant for the specific commercial space.

For example, when a business seeks to lease retail space in a mall, the landlord may evaluate the business’s financial statements, current customer base, and the owner’s previous experience in managing similar ventures.

Key factors that should be considered during commercial tenant screening include:

  1. Business Financial Health: The first and most important aspect to check is the financial stability of the business. This includes checking business credit reports, financial statements such as income statements and balance sheets, and tax returns. These documents provide insights into the business’s income, debts, and overall financial stability. For example, a coffee shop that wishes to lease space must provide these financial documents, which would demonstrate its ability to meet monthly lease payments.
  2. Business Plan: A well-crafted business plan can provide a comprehensive view of the prospective tenant’s business, including details about the product or service, market analysis, marketing strategies, and financial projections. This can help the property owner understand how the business plans to succeed in the market and how it will generate the revenue needed to pay the rent.
  3. Industry Experience: It is critical to understand the prospective tenant’s experience in the industry. A business that is run by experienced professionals is more likely to succeed and hence more likely to fulfill lease obligations. Inquiring about the tenant’s business experience, years in operation, and references from previous landlords or business partners can provide valuable insights.
  4. Legal Compliance: The property owner must verify if the prospective tenant is in compliance with all relevant laws and regulations. This includes checking if the business has the necessary licenses and permits and if it has a history of legal issues or disputes.
  5. Suitability for the Space: Last but not least, the property owner should consider whether the business is a suitable tenant for the specific commercial property. For example, a manufacturing unit might not be a suitable tenant for a property in a residential area due to noise and pollution issues. Conversely, a quiet office space might be an ideal tenant for a building in a business district.

Commercial tenant screening is a meticulous and thorough process that involves examining various business-related factors. It encompasses more than just rent payment assurance; it also aims to determine if the tenant’s business aligns well with the property. A strong alignment increases the likelihood of long-term tenancy, fostering a stable and mutually beneficial landlord-tenant relationship.

Tenant Screening Process

Commercial tenant screening can be a complex process, but it’s essential for minimizing risk and ensuring a successful long-term leasing relationship. Here is a detailed, step-by-step guide to the process:

Step 1: Application

Start by having the prospective tenant fill out an application. This should include key information about the tenant and their business, including business name, type of business, years in operation, ownership details, and financial information. The application should also request references from previous landlords or property managers, business partners, and other relevant contacts.

Step 2: Preliminary Assessment

Conduct a preliminary assessment based on the application. Look at the nature of the business, how long it’s been in operation, and whether it appears to be a good fit for your property. This step can help you quickly weed out tenants who clearly don’t meet your criteria.

Step 3: Credit Check

Run a credit check on the business (and sometimes the business owners, especially in the case of small businesses). This will give you a sense of the business’s financial health and reliability. You’ll need the applicant’s permission to run a credit check. In some cases, you may want to ask for a personal guarantee, especially for startups or small businesses with a limited credit history.

Step 4: Financial Review

Go deeper into the business’s finances by reviewing its financial statements, including income statements, balance sheets, and cash flow statements. This review can provide a clearer picture of the business’s financial stability and its ability to meet lease obligations. A business with strong, steady cash flow and a healthy balance sheet is likely to be a reliable tenant.

Step 5: Review Business Plan

Ask for and review the business’s plan. This should give you an understanding of the business’s products or services, its target market, and its growth projections. The business plan can help you determine whether the business has a viable path to sustained profitability, which in turn will help ensure they can continue to pay the rent.

Step 6: Verify Legal Compliance

Check to ensure the business is legally compliant. This includes checking that the business has all necessary licenses and permits for its operation and doesn’t have a history of legal disputes or issues. You can check public records and possibly consult with a legal expert to ensure the business is in good legal standing.

Step 7: Check References

Contact the provided references to learn more about the business’s reliability and reputation. This can include previous landlords, business partners, suppliers, or even customers. Their insights can be invaluable in determining whether the business will be a reliable and responsible tenant.

Step 8: Negotiate Lease Terms

If the tenant passes the screening process, the next step is to negotiate lease terms. This includes not just the rent, but also other factors like the lease duration, responsibilities for maintenance and repairs, lease renewal options, and so on. A lawyer can be very helpful during this phase to ensure your interests are protected.

Step 9: Prepare the Lease Agreement

Once you’ve agreed on terms, prepare the lease agreement. This is a legally binding document that outlines the terms and conditions of the lease. Both you and the tenant should review this document carefully before signing.

Step 10: Finalize the Agreement

After a thorough review, both parties can sign the lease agreement. Once the lease is signed, the tenant can begin preparing to move into the commercial space.

Remember, while this process may seem lengthy, each step is crucial in ensuring that you’re selecting the right tenant for your property. It can significantly reduce the risk of leasing to a problematic tenant and can contribute to a stable and profitable leasing relationship.

Legal Aspects of Tenant Screening

In the process of tenant screening, it’s crucial to be mindful of legal aspects, particularly the Fair Housing laws and privacy laws. Missteps in either area can lead to serious legal consequences.

Fair Housing Laws

Fair Housing laws are designed to prevent discrimination in the renting, selling, or financing of housing based on certain protected characteristics. In the U.S., the Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, and national origin. Some states and local jurisdictions have additional protections, such as sexual orientation, gender identity, and marital status.

In the context of commercial tenant screening, while the Fair Housing Act primarily pertains to residential properties, similar principles of non-discrimination apply. For instance, the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits discrimination in all types of property transactions, including commercial leasing, on the basis of race, color, religion, or national origin.

When screening commercial tenants, ensure that you treat all applicants equally and make decisions based on objective, business-related criteria such as financial stability, business plan, and suitability for the space. Any process or criteria that disproportionately exclude certain groups could potentially be seen as discriminatory, even if unintentionally so.

Privacy Laws

Privacy laws govern what information you can collect from potential tenants, how you can use it, and how you must store and dispose of it. There are several important privacy laws to keep in mind during the screening process.

The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) is a federal law that regulates the collection and use of consumer credit information. Even though commercial transactions are typically not covered by FCRA, when you’re dealing with small businesses, you might find yourself evaluating the personal credit of the business owner. In such cases, you must obtain the applicant’s written permission before you can access their credit report.

Furthermore, various state laws may impose additional privacy requirements. For example, in California, the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) gives consumers the right to know what personal information businesses collect about them, why it’s being collected, and who it’s shared with.

It’s also crucial to handle all personal information collected during the tenant screening process with care. This includes securely storing the information and disposing of it once it’s no longer needed. You should have a clear privacy policy explaining how you handle personal information and ensure that your practices align with this policy.

Lastly, while conducting reference checks, you should also respect the privacy of the individuals providing the references. Only ask questions that are relevant to the potential tenant’s suitability and avoid asking about personal matters that don’t pertain to the business relationship.

Given the complexity of legal compliance, you may want to consult with a legal expert to ensure that your tenant screening process is in line with all relevant laws and regulations. Doing so can help protect you from potential legal issues down the line.

Key Information to Gather

When screening potential commercial tenants, gathering and verifying the right information is crucial. The information you collect will help you assess the prospective tenant’s financial health, business reputation, and overall suitability for the space. Here are some key pieces of information you should gather:

  1. Business Details: Gather general information about the business such as the business name, the type of business, the number of years in operation, and the ownership details. You should also ask for details about the business’s operations, such as number of employees, products or services offered, and expected customer traffic.
  2. Financial Information: Financial information is key to assessing the potential tenant’s ability to meet lease obligations. This includes the business’s financial statements (balance sheet, income statement, cash flow statement), tax returns, and business credit reports. For small businesses or startups, you may also want to ask for the owner’s personal financial information, as the business’s financial health may be closely tied to the owner’s financial health.
  3. Business Plan: The business plan can provide valuable insights into the prospective tenant’s business strategy and financial projections. It can help you assess whether the business has a viable plan to generate the revenue needed to pay rent.
  4. References: Ask for references from previous landlords, business partners, suppliers, or even major customers. These references can provide insights into the business’s reliability, reputation, and financial stability.
  5. Legal Compliance: Ask for proof of the business’s compliance with relevant laws and regulations. This includes necessary licenses and permits for the business’s operations, as well as evidence of good standing with regulatory bodies.

Once you’ve gathered this information, it’s crucial to verify it. Here’s why:

  1. Ensuring Accuracy: Verifying the information helps ensure that it’s accurate and that the prospective tenant hasn’t provided false or misleading information. For instance, you should cross-check the financial information provided with the business credit report and verify ownership details with state business records.
  2. Assessing Reliability: Verification can help assess the reliability of the prospective tenant. If a tenant is willing to provide false or misleading information during the screening process, it raises serious concerns about their reliability and trustworthiness.
  3. Legal Compliance: In some cases, verification is necessary for legal compliance. For instance, you’re required to verify that the prospective tenant has the necessary licenses and permits for their business operations.

Verification can take various forms, including checking public records, contacting references, consulting with financial experts or legal advisors, and using third-party tenant screening services. Remember, the goal of verification isn’t to be intrusive or suspicious, but rather to ensure that you’re making an informed decision about who to lease your property to.

Evaluating Business Credit Reports and Financial Stability

Interpreting Business Credit Reports

A business credit report is a comprehensive record that shows how a business handles its financial obligations. It includes information about a business’s credit history, such as loans, lines of credit, payment history, and any instances of bankruptcy or late payments.

There are several major credit bureaus that generate business credit reports, including Experian, Equifax, and Dun & Bradstreet. These reports generally provide a credit score or rating for the business, similar to a personal credit score. Here’s how you can interpret a business credit report:

  1. Credit Score: The business credit score is a numerical representation of the business’s creditworthiness. A high score indicates that the business has a good history of repaying its debts on time, while a low score suggests a higher risk of late payments or default. Each bureau has its own scoring model, so it’s important to understand what the scores mean for each specific report.
  2. Payment History: Review the business’s payment history to see if they have a history of paying their bills on time. Late payments or defaults are a red flag.
  3. Debt Utilization: Look at how much debt the business is carrying relative to its available credit. High debt utilization can be a sign of financial stress.
  4. Public Records: The report will include public records such as bankruptcies, judgments, or liens. These can also be indicators of financial trouble.
  5. Company Information: The report will also include information about the company’s size, industry, and years in operation. This can help you assess the business’s stability and experience.

Analyzing Financial Statements

Analyzing a business’s financial statements can give you deeper insights into its financial stability. Here’s what to look for:

  1. Income Statement: The income statement shows the business’s revenue, costs, and profits. Look for steady or growing revenue and a healthy profit margin. Significant fluctuations in revenue or consistently low profits could be a sign of instability.
  2. Balance Sheet: The balance sheet provides a snapshot of the business’s assets, liabilities, and equity at a specific point in time. A strong balance sheet has a good balance between assets and liabilities. High levels of debt relative to assets, or insufficient assets to cover short-term liabilities, can be red flags.
  3. Cash Flow Statement: The cash flow statement shows how cash moves in and out of the business. Positive cash flow from operations indicates that the business is generating enough cash from its regular operations to cover its expenses. Negative cash flow from operations could suggest financial problems.
  4. Financial Ratios: Various financial ratios can also be helpful. For instance, the current ratio (current assets divided by current liabilities) indicates the business’s ability to pay its short-term debts, while the debt-to-equity ratio (total debt divided by total equity) provides insights into the business’s financial leverage.

Remember, while strong financials are a good sign, they’re just one piece of the puzzle. A business with strong financials might still be a poor fit for your property for other reasons, such as not being compliant with relevant laws or not aligning with the property’s target tenant mix. Similarly, a business with less-than-stellar financials might still be a good tenant if it has a solid business plan and experienced management. It’s important to consider all aspects of the prospective tenant’s business when making your decision.

Reference Checks

Conducting reference checks is a valuable part of the tenant screening process. It can provide insights into the prospective tenant’s reliability, reputation, and past behavior that you might not be able to glean from financial statements or credit reports. Here’s how you can effectively conduct reference checks:

1. Identify the Right References

When collecting references from a prospective tenant, aim for a mix of professional references that can speak to different aspects of the tenant’s business. This can include previous landlords or property managers, business partners, suppliers, or even major customers. Avoid personal references, as they may not provide an unbiased perspective.

2. Prepare Your Questions

Before you contact the references, prepare your questions. The questions should be open-ended and focused on the potential tenant’s suitability as a tenant. Some possible questions include:

  • Can you describe your professional relationship with the prospective tenant?
  • How long have you known or done business with the prospective tenant?
  • Has the tenant consistently met their financial obligations on time?
  • How has the tenant handled any issues or conflicts that have arisen?
  • Would you do business with this tenant again in the future?

Avoid asking about personal matters that don’t pertain to the business relationship.

3. Make the Call

When you call the reference, introduce yourself, explain why you’re calling, and confirm that it’s a good time for them to talk. Be respectful of their time and keep the conversation focused on the questions you prepared.

4. Document the Conversation

Take detailed notes during the conversation. Write down the reference’s responses to your questions as accurately as possible, and also note any other relevant comments they make. These notes will be valuable when you’re reviewing the information later.

5. Evaluate the Responses

After you’ve completed all the reference checks, review the responses. Look for consistent themes or patterns across different references. Also, consider the responses in the context of the other information you’ve gathered about the prospective tenant. The reference checks are just one piece of the puzzle.

Remember, while reference checks can provide valuable insights, they should not be the sole basis of your decision. Some people may feel uncomfortable providing a negative reference, so it’s important to also consider the other information you’ve gathered about the prospective tenant.

If a prospective tenant hesitates to provide references or the references don’t provide positive feedback, it could be a red flag. However, it’s important to follow up and ask for clarification if something seems off. There could be a reasonable explanation, or it might indicate that the prospective tenant isn’t the right fit for your property.

And if you are fortunate enough to retain your tenant, I invite you to take a moment and indulge in reading this article that I have written. It delves into the captivating realm of The Art of Tenant Retention, offering valuable insights on how to effectively nurture and maintain long-lasting relationships with your esteemed clients. Discover the secrets to ensuring client satisfaction and fostering loyalty in this ever-evolving landscape of property management.

Drafting a Commercial Lease Agreement

A commercial lease agreement is a legally binding contract between the landlord and tenant that outlines the terms and conditions of the lease. Here are some key points to include in a commercial lease agreement:

  • Parties Involved: The lease should clearly identify the landlord and tenant. If the tenant is a business entity, ensure that the lease is with the business and not with an individual.
  • Premises: Define the leased premises clearly. This could be a suite number, a floor, a whole building, or even a parcel of land. If there are any common areas that the tenant will have access to, these should also be defined.
  • Lease Term: Specify the duration of the lease, including the start date and end date. Also, include any options to renew the lease and the terms for such renewal.
  • Rent: Clearly define the amount of rent, when it’s due, and how it should be paid. If there are any escalations or rent increases during the lease term, these should also be defined.
  • Security Deposit: Detail the amount of the security deposit, when and how it should be paid, and the conditions under which it will be returned or withheld at the end of the lease.
  • Maintenance and Repairs: Specify who is responsible for maintaining and repairing different parts of the property. This typically includes the tenant’s responsibilities for maintaining their space and the landlord’s responsibilities for maintaining common areas and structural elements.
  • Use of the Premises: Define what the premises can and cannot be used for. This should align with the tenant’s intended use of the space.
  • Insurance and Liability: Outline the insurance requirements for the tenant and landlord, and specify who is responsible for any damages or injuries that occur on the property.
  • Default and Remedies: Define what constitutes a default on the lease, and what remedies are available to the landlord in the event of a default.
  • Termination: Specify the conditions under which the lease can be terminated, and what happens in the event of early termination.
  • Assignment and Subletting: State whether the tenant is allowed to assign the lease or sublet the space, and under what conditions.
  • Dispute Resolution: Detail how disputes related to the lease will be resolved, whether through mediation, arbitration, or litigation.
  • Miscellaneous: Include any other provisions that are relevant to your specific situation, such as rules and regulations, improvements and alterations, signage, and environmental issues.

It’s essential to consult with a legal expert when drafting a commercial lease agreement. Commercial leases can be complex, and it’s important to ensure that the lease protects your interests and complies with all relevant laws and regulations. A legal expert can help you understand the implications of different lease provisions and guide you in drafting a fair and enforceable lease agreement.

tenant screening for commercial properties

Tenant Screening for Commercial Properties FAQs

What kind of information should I gather from potential tenants?

It’s important to ask for more than just the basics, such as name and phone number. You should also ask for employment details, income, and references. This will give you a better idea of the person’s financial stability and responsibility. Additionally, consider asking about their rental history, including why they are moving and if they have any past issues with landlords.

How do I analyze a business credit report?

The payment history holds utmost importance as it serves as an indicator of your future payment behavior, specifically in terms of timeliness. Several other crucial factors can influence your business credit score, including the length of your credit history, the total debt you carry, the industry your business operates in, and the size of your company.

What is the role of financial stability in the tenant screening process?

When it comes to renting out a property, landlords want to make sure that their tenants are financially stable enough to consistently pay rent on time and in full. That’s why financial stability plays a crucial role in the tenant screening process. During this process, landlords examine a potential tenant’s credit score and financial history to determine their ability to pay rent and any other associated costs. This not only helps protect the landlord’s financial investment, but it also helps ensure that the tenant can comfortably fulfill their financial obligations.

How do I conduct effective reference checks?

First, come up with a list of questions that will help you delve deeper into the candidate’s skills, work style, and past experience. Don’t be afraid to ask follow-up questions if the reference’s responses are vague or incomplete. Also, make sure to confirm that the reference is who they say they are and that they actually have a relationship with the candidate. And most importantly, listen carefully to what the reference is saying (and not saying) – their answers can provide valuable insight into the candidate’s strengths, weaknesses, and overall fit for the role.

What are the essential points to include in a commercial lease agreement?

When drafting a commercial lease, it is important to include essential points that will protect the interests of both parties. These points include the lease term, rent, security deposit, use and maintenance of the property, restrictions, permission for alterations, insurance, subletting, and termination clauses. It is also important to clearly define any additional fees that may be incurred, such as utilities and property taxes.


Conducting the right tenant screening for your commercial property is very important to your financial security. An experienced attorney who specializes in landlord-tenant law can provide helpful advice on the best procedures and legal requirements when collecting information from potential tenants.

Additionally, a credit report agency familiar with interpreting business credit can help you analyze any potential tenant’s potential to pay back rent or other fees. Ultimately, the process of properly screening tenants can avoid future problems and create a mutually beneficial relationship between landlord and tenant.

Furthermore, learning how to make sure all of these steps are followed is key to ensuring success in your rental properties. Therefore, take this knowledge and put it into action now by calling or setting up an appointment for a free consultation. This is one action that could provide long-lasting peace of mind when it comes to managing rental properties!

Blog Articles Disclaimer

The information presented in articles on our website or affiliated platforms is exclusively intended for informational purposes. It’s crucial to grasp that this content does not constitute professional advice or services. We strongly recommend our readers to seek guidance from appropriately qualified experts, including, but not limited to, real estate and other attorneys, accountants, financial planners, bankers, mortgage professionals, architects, government officials, engineers, and related professionals. These experts can offer personalized counsel tailored to the specific nuances of your individual circumstances. Relying on the content without consulting the relevant experts may hinder informed decision-making. Consequently, neither Tolj Commercial Real Estate nor its agents assume any responsibility for potential consequences that may arise from such action.

Similar Posts