Commercial Lease Renewal

Commercial Lease Renewal Best Practices for CA Tenants

Mike Tolj

Mike Tolj

Mike Tolj specializes in representing business owners and landlords in the leasing and sale of commercial properties. He has over 18 years of experience in the industry and knows how to get deals done quickly and efficiently. Mike is passionate about helping business owners and landlords alike achieve their real estate goals. He has a track record of achievement, having completed numerous transactions for his clients.

More About Mike

Share

A commercial lease renewal is not automatic. It is either a new deal or an option deal, and either way it starts on a clock set by your existing lease, not by when you happen to think about it. The tenants who get the best renewal terms are the ones who start early and arrive with a file, not just a phone call to the landlord’s office.

This guide is for California business tenants preparing for a renewal. It covers what to check in your lease, how your type of tenancy affects your rights, how to assess your space needs and the market, how to plan your timeline and your ask, when walking away is the better choice, and how to document the result. If you are an owner planning a rollover, see our owner’s guide to lease renewals and rent increases.

Key Takeaways

  • Your lease sets the clock. Option notice deadlines are usually separate from the expiration date, and missing one can cost you the option.
  • Know your tenancy type. An option, an open negotiation, a holdover and a month-to-month tenancy each work differently.
  • Start from your business, then the market. Decide what space and terms you need before you look at what the market says.
  • Compare staying with moving on total cost, not only base rent.
  • Put the agreement in writing and keep a record of what was agreed.

Audit Your Current Lease First

Commercial Lease Renewal Best Practices

Before you talk to anyone, whether the landlord, a broker or an attorney, pull your actual lease and every amendment and confirm the basics in writing. Do not rely on memory or on what you think the deal says.

  • Expiration date. When does the current term actually end?
  • Renewal or option language. Do you have a formal option to renew, or is this an open negotiation once the term ends? Options usually come with their own notice deadlines, separate from the lease’s expiration date.
  • Base rent. What are you paying today, and how is it structured: flat, stepped or percentage?
  • Escalators. Is there a fixed annual increase, a CPI-linked increase or something else?
  • CAM and NNN charges. If you are on a triple net structure, you pay taxes, insurance and common area maintenance separately from base rent. Get the last 12 months of CAM reconciliations if you can.
  • Transfer rights. What does the lease say about subleasing or assigning?
  • Guarantee and security deposit. Is there a personal guarantee, and what is the status of your deposit?
  • Holdover terms. What does the lease say if you stay after expiration?
  • Condition and return obligations. What must you do to the space if you leave?

If any of this is unclear from the document, ask your attorney or broker before renewal talks start. Do not guess during negotiation.

How Your Tenancy Type Affects Renewal

What happens at the end of your term depends on what kind of tenancy you have.

You have a renewal option. An option is a right already written into your lease, usually with its own notice deadline and delivery method, and sometimes with pre-set rent terms or a rent formula such as a fixed amount or fair market value. If you want to use it, follow the lease exactly.

You have no option. Renewal is an open negotiation. More is up for discussion, and less is guaranteed.

Your lease ends and you stay. California law presumes that if a tenant stays in possession after a lease ends and the landlord accepts rent, the parties have renewed on the same terms, for no more than a month if rent is paid monthly (Civil Code section 1945). Courts have found this presumption arose in commercial cases where a landlord kept accepting rent. That can give you time, but it is a month-to-month position, not a renewal, and it can be ended with notice. Do not rely on it as a plan.

You are month-to-month and may be a qualified commercial tenant. California’s SB 1103 took effect on 1 January 2025 and gives certain small businesses, called qualified commercial tenants, extra protection in month-to-month and similar tenancies. A qualified commercial tenant is a defined group that includes microenterprises and some small restaurants and nonprofits. For these tenants, a landlord must give written notice of at least 30 days for a rent increase of 10% or less and at least 90 days for an increase above 10%, measured against the rent charged in the prior 12 months. Termination notice rules also changed. The law has its own definitions and conditions, including how a tenant makes its qualified status known to the landlord, so ask your attorney whether it applies to you. It is aimed at month-to-month and shorter tenancies and does not change a fixed-term lease.

Residential rent rules, such as California’s residential rent cap, do not apply to commercial leases.

Check Your Space Needs Before You Negotiate Anything

A renewal conversation should start with your business, not the market. Before you decide what to ask for, get honest answers to these questions:

  • Does the current square footage still fit your headcount, inventory or operations, or have you outgrown it or shrunk into it?
  • Are there layout or functional problems with the space that a renewal is your chance to fix?
  • Do you have plans in the next 12 to 24 months, such as hiring, downsizing or a new product line, that change what you need from this location?
  • Is this location still working for your customers, employees and supply chain?

If the space still works, that is useful leverage. You can negotiate from “we would like to stay”, which is different from “we are stuck”.

Use Comps as Questions, Not Assumptions

It is tempting to walk into a renewal assuming you know what market rent is for your area. Do not guess, and do not rely on a rent figure you saw online without knowing when it was current or how comparable the property is.

Instead, ask your broker or attorney to help you answer:

  • What have comparable buildings in this specific submarket actually leased for recently, meaning signed deals and not asking rents?
  • How does our building’s condition, parking, visibility or access compare to those comps?
  • Has ownership or property management changed recently in a way that could affect flexibility?
  • Is space in this submarket generally easy or hard to find right now?

These are questions to bring to a professional with current, verifiable data. A blog post, including this one, cannot answer them.

Know What Each Side Wants

Tenants and landlords are rarely negotiating over the same single issue, and knowing the other side’s priorities changes how you structure your ask.

Tenants typically care about: predictable costs, flexibility on term length, the right to sublease or assign if plans change, and not overpaying for space they no longer need.

Landlords typically care about: avoiding vacancy and re-leasing costs, keeping a stable, creditworthy tenant in place, and protecting the building’s rent roll for financing or resale. For how an owner prepares, see the owner’s guide to lease renewals and rent increases.

A landlord who wants to avoid downtime may have more room on rent than on term length. A tenant who values stability over savings may get further by asking for a longer term at a smaller increase than by fighting hard on base rent. Know which trade-offs matter to you before you are in the room.

Build Your Timeline

Missing a notice deadline can mean losing your option rights entirely, so do not leave this until the last minute. Before you do anything else, confirm:

  • Does your lease require written notice to exercise a renewal option, and by what date?
  • How must notice be delivered (certified mail, email or hand delivery), and to which address or party?
  • If you miss the option window, what does the lease say happens next?
  • Is there a separate deadline for negotiating a fresh lease if there is no formal option?
  • Who on your team tracks this date, and is it calendared with a buffer?

Then work backward from the earliest deadline. Allow time to review the lease, assess your needs, gather market information, negotiate and have counsel review the documents. If a move is a real possibility, add the time to find space, negotiate and build it out. Starting early gives you options. Starting late removes them.

Plan Your Ask

Before you open the conversation, decide what you want and what you would trade. Common items include:

  • Rent and escalations. Base rent, how it increases, and whether it is a gross, modified gross or triple net structure.
  • Term and flexibility. Length of the new term, and whether you want an option to renew again.
  • Concessions. Free rent, a tenant improvement allowance, or repairs to be completed before renewal.
  • Space changes. Expansion, contraction or layout changes.
  • Transfer rights. The right to sublease or assign if plans change.
  • Credit support. Whether a personal guarantee or deposit can be reduced or limited.
  • Building issues. Deferred maintenance or services that affect your business.

Look at the whole package, not only base rent. Total cost of occupancy includes escalations, operating expenses and any credits. Our lease negotiation tips for business tenants explain how to compare proposals this way.

When Not to Renew

Renewal is not always the right move, and it is worth considering the alternative before you commit to another term.

  • The space no longer fits your operations, and the cost of fixing that (build-out, expansion) rivals the cost of moving.
  • The landlord is not willing to address deferred maintenance or building issues that affect your business.
  • The location has stopped serving your customers, employees or logistics needs.
  • You have a real opportunity elsewhere that is worth the disruption of moving.

If you are on the fence, ask a broker to run the numbers on both paths, staying and relocating, before you sign anything. Include the costs of a move: build-out, relocation, downtime and disruption for customers and staff, as well as the rent on the new space.

Renewal File: What to Pull Before the Meeting

Item to gatherWhy it matters
Full current lease plus any amendmentsConfirms actual terms, not assumed ones
Option and renewal notice languageConfirms deadlines and the required delivery method
Last 12 months of CAM and NNN statementsShows the real occupancy cost trend, not just base rent
Internal space needs notes (headcount, layout issues, growth plans)Anchors your ask in your business, not just the market
Recent comparable lease data from your brokerReplaces guesses about market rent with signed deals
List of unresolved maintenance or building issuesGives you negotiating leverage or grounds to walk
Staying versus moving cost comparisonShows whether renewal is actually your best option
Names and contact information for your broker and attorneySo they can be brought in before, not after, terms are discussed

Put the Agreement in Writing

Commercial Lease Renewal

A verbal understanding is not a renewal. When you reach terms, make sure they are in a signed renewal lease or amendment before the old term ends. Check that the document covers:

  • the new term, rent and escalations,
  • any concessions, allowances or promised repairs and who does the work,
  • operating expense terms,
  • whether renewal options remain,
  • the guarantee and security deposit,
  • subleasing and assignment rights,
  • repair and maintenance responsibilities.

Keep copies of the signed document and the correspondence that led to it. Have an attorney review the final document before you sign.

FAQs

When should you start a commercial lease renewal?

There is no single date. Start well before any option deadline in your lease, early enough to review the lease, assess your space needs and negotiate without pressure from an approaching expiration. If a move is possible, start earlier still.

What is the difference between exercising a lease option and negotiating a new lease?

A lease option is a right already written into your existing lease, usually with its own notice deadline and sometimes pre-set rent terms. A new lease negotiation happens when there is no option, or when either side wants terms outside what the option allows. More is open for discussion, but less is guaranteed.

What happens if you miss the option deadline?

Check your lease first, since it may say what happens next. Missing the deadline can end your right to renew on the option’s terms, and you may then be negotiating a new lease or facing a month-to-month tenancy or a move. Ask your attorney as soon as you realize a deadline has passed.

Can a landlord raise your rent during a fixed lease term?

Generally only if your lease provides for it, for example through scheduled escalations, or if you agree to an amendment. Month-to-month tenancies follow different notice rules, including the SB 1103 rules for qualified commercial tenants described above.

Can lease renewals be finalized without legal counsel?

It is possible, but a lease renewal is a legally binding contract, so it is wise to have an attorney review it before you sign.

What are the benefits of negotiating a renewal early?

An early start gives you more time to explore options, a better chance of favorable terms, and a buffer if negotiations take longer than expected.

Conclusion

A good renewal starts with preparation: know your lease and your deadlines, understand your tenancy type, decide what your business needs, and compare staying with moving. If you would like a second set of eyes on your lease terms or timeline, our tenant and buyer representation team can help you prepare before you sit down with the landlord. For a breakdown of costs that are often missed during renewal, see our guide to hidden lease costs. To talk through your situation, schedule a consultation.

Blog Articles Disclaimer

The information presented in articles on our website or affiliated platforms is exclusively intended for informational purposes. It’s crucial to grasp that this content does not constitute professional advice or services. We strongly recommend our readers to seek guidance from appropriately qualified experts, including, but not limited to, real estate and other attorneys, accountants, financial planners, bankers, mortgage professionals, architects, government officials, engineers, and related professionals. These experts can offer personalized counsel tailored to the specific nuances of your individual circumstances. Relying on the content without consulting the relevant experts may hinder informed decision-making. Consequently, neither Tolj Commercial Real Estate nor its agents assume any responsibility for potential consequences that may arise from such action.

Related Articles

Get Expert Guidance

Skip to content